The Bay House Menu
Welcome to The Bay House, a gem nestled in Naples, Florida, where Southern charm meets fresh seafood delight. This classy establishment boasts a diverse menu that caters to every palate, with savory vegetarian options complementing its rich seafood offerings. Start with the Crispy Flash-Fried Cauliflower or indulge in the World's Best Pimento Cheese—both celebrated for their flavor and creativity.
- Starters & Salads: The Bay House balances tradition and innovation, offering classics like the Caesar Salad along with the refreshing Raw Cauliflower Salad.
- Main Entrees: Savor the Seared King Scallops or the robust 12 oz. Prime NY Strip Steak, each dish meticulously prepared to tantalize your taste buds.
- Atmosphere: With outdoor seating and live music enhancing your dining experience, this venue is perfect for families or groups.
Join us for dinner, and let the flavors of The Bay House captivate your senses.
Chilled Seafood
Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
Pine Island Jumbo Crab Cocktail
Alaskan King Crab
Whole Maine Lobster
Market Oysters Dozen
Market Oysters Claw Bar Dozen 13
Big Island Tuna Poke
Citrus soy, toasted sesame, pickled ginger, cucumbers & carrot, rice crackers
Seasonal Watermelon Poke
Citrus soy, toasted sesame, pickled ginger, cucumbers & carrot, rice crackers
Bayhouse Ceviche
Marinated shrimp, gulf fish, bay scallops, citrus & jalapeno
Claw Bar Special
3 oysters, crab, 2 shrimp, seafood salad, house-made pickles, trio of sauces, crackers
Low Rise
6 shrimp, crab, 6 oysters, half lobster, seafood salad, house-made pickles, trio of sauces, crackers
High Rise
12 shrimp, crab, 12 oysters, whole lobster, seafood salad, house-made pickles, pimento cheese, trio of sauces, crackers
Chilled Seafood Towers
Hot Seafood
Creamy Corn & Crab Bisque
Charred corn and crab garnish
Crispy Fried Oysters
Bayou remoulade
Lobster & Lump Crab Potholes
Garlic herb butter
Steamed Mussels
Crushed tomato, rosé wine, roasted garlic chips, chorizo, queso fresco, French bread croutons
Char-Grilled Octopus
Farro & sriracha aioli
Crispy Flash-Fried Cauliflower
Curry dusted, sriracha pepper aioli
World's Best Pimento Cheese
Our pimento cheese, cracker basket
Bay House Caesar
Romaine, herbed croutons, shaved Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Dressing, White anchovy
Raw Cauliflower Salad
Pickled Red Onion, Bacon, Parsley, Parmesan Dressing
Iceberg Wedge Salad
Pickled red onion, heirloom cherry tomatoes, Nueske's bacon, buttermilk ranch, Gorgonzola, cornbread croutons
South of Broad
Fried green tomatoes, herbed goat cheese, tomato jam, pepper jelly vinaigrette, basil
Chef Jamie's Cornbread
Honey butter
The Farmer's Salad
Celebrating the bounty of our local farmer friends
Specialties & Salads
Tavern Standards
The Butcher's Tavern Burger
Short rib, brisket & sirloin blend, secret sauce, pimento cheese, bacon, pickled red onion, butter lettuce, brioche bun, salt & pepper fries
The "Sea BLT"
A chilled salad of lobster, shrimp, crab & mayonnaise, fried green tomatoes, smoked bacon, roasted corn, smoked tomato vinaigrette
Steak Frites
Petite beef tenderloin, béarnaise, salt & pepper frites, dressed rocket salad
Seared King Scallops
Lemon infused cauliflower risotto, roasted baby carrots, mint pistachio pesto
12 oz. Prime NY Strip Steak
Fingerling potatoes, charred Brussels sprouts, Nueske's bacon, caramelized onions, compound butter, demi
House Jerk-Marinated Swordfish
Sweet potato puree, wilted greens, pickled shiitake mushrooms, pepper jelly vinaigrette
Roasted Black Cod
Crispy, sticky rice cake, citrus soy & ginger butter sauce, haricot vert, shiitake mushrooms
Charleston Carpetbagger Steak
Petite filet with crispy fried oysters, fingerling potatoes, wilted greens, bayou remoulade, steak sauce
St. Augustine Stew
Crab, shrimp, fish, mussels & lobster with rice in a spicy pepper broth, French bread croutons
Berkshire Pork Prime Rib Chop
Sweet potato puree, roasted Brussels sprouts, chipotle cherry chutney
Pan-Seared Salmon
Lemon infused cauliflower risotto, warm lobster salad, asparagus
BBQ Shrimp & Grits
Heirloom grits, spinach, tasso, horseradish cream
Nashville Chicken
Roasted Bell & Evans chicken, dill spaetzle, hot sauce butter sauce, savoy cabbage, honey gastrique
Gulf Black Grouper
Oven roasted, andouille-mushroom risotto, jumbo lump crab, asparagus, charred tomato vinaigrette
Paris Bistro-Style Lobster & Frites
Split herb butter grilled tail, béarnaise, salt & pepper frites, dressed rocket salad
